Can the Meritocracy Find God?
The secularization of America probably won’t reverse unless the intelligentsia gets religion.
By Ross Douthat
Quote
Most of these people — my people, by tribe and education — would be unlikely models of holiness in any dispensation, given their ambitions and their worldliness. But Jesus endorsed the wisdom of serpents as well as the innocence of doves, and religious communities no less than secular ones rely on talent and ambition. So the deep secularization of the meritocracy means that people who would once have become priests and ministers and rabbis become psychologists or social workers or professors, people who might once have run missions go to work for NGOs instead, and guilt-ridden moguls who might once have funded religious charities salve their consciences by starting secular foundations.
Ah, what a lovely way to begin my evening reading Ross. Thank you.
Now, how can this process be accelerated?
Quote
As a Christian inhabitant of this world, I often try to imagine what it would take for the meritocracy to get religion. There are certain ways in which its conversion doesn’t seem unimaginable. A lot of progressive ideas about social justice still make more sense as part of a biblical framework...
You're overlooking one important factor, Ross. The hocus-pocus explanatory framework provided by religions are just bronze age garbage. These just don't work. Their functions are better fulfilled by science, philosophy and ethics, and politics, In order for the progressive ideas of social justice to arise and to prevail one does not need a biblical framework. Have you noticed religious people are the most opposed to ideas of social justice when justice rendered reduces their power?
All the good deeds of religions can be done without harkening to superstitions, the need of belief without evidence. The only ways for religions to regain their place of prominence are through bamboozlement and force. Surely enough, those are the paths most taken by religions.